Reactions to Argo Best Picture Win

Robert Sheer in TruthDig .. “Oscar 2013: Hollywood’s CIA Celebration”:

After the overthrow of the shah in 1979, I interviewed for the Los Angeles Times CIA operative Kermit Roosevelt, who led the coup against Mossadegh. For a quarter century, the United States had denied any connection with the coup, but Roosevelt, a grandson of President Theodore Roosevelt, was about to release a tell-all book on the subject that the CIA had approved, and he was willing to talk .. Roosevelt told me that he and Dulles kept their plan secret from Truman and his secretary of state, Dean Acheson, because they were sympathetic to Mossadegh as a genuine nationalist leader. “Acheson was absolutely fascinated by Dr. Mossadegh. He was in fact sympathetic to him,” Roosevelt said [] Instead, he waited until Allen Dulles’ brother, Foster, took over as secretary of state in the incoming Republican administration, and then Dr. Mossadegh would come to be defined by the U.S. as a potential puppet of the Soviets. In our interview, 25 years after the coup, Roosevelt was at pains to say that in retrospect, the communist label didn’t really fit. “Mossadegh was not pro-communist. … I think that the British were very stupid in negotiations with Mossadegh. … “I think it was possible to make an offer he would have accepted and that would have avoided this whole blowup. If they had said, ‘OK, we’ll increase the rate (paid to Iran for their oil) we’ll give you a certain percentage of the ownership,’ this would have been the smart thing for them to do.”

and here’s Robert Parry in Consortium News: The Shortsighted History of ‘Argo’ ..

Despite a brief documentary-style opening referencing the 1953 coup and the dictatorial rule of the Shah of Iran until 1979, Argo quickly descended into a formulaic tale of sympathetic CIA officers trying to outwit nasty Iranian revolutionaries, complete with a totally made-up thriller escape at the end .. In that sense, Argo recalls Charlie Wilson’s War, which presented a dangerously misleading account of the Soviets’ war in Afghanistan. Though “just a movie,” Charlie Wilson’s War’s storyline has become something of a baseline for America’s understanding of the historic challenges in Afghanistan

i for one was surprised that Argo mentioned the Mossadegh coup at all – usually mainstream media, TV, movies, news etc omit that whole chapter – baby steps – mab

 

 

This entry was posted on Tuesday, February 26th, 2013 at 8:42 AM and filed under Articles, Arts, Energy, FBI/CIA/NSA/DHS/DEA, Foreign Affairs, History, Middle East. Follow comments here with the RSS 2.0 feed. Skip to the end and leave a response. Trackbacks are closed.

One Response to “Reactions to Argo Best Picture Win”

  1. Harry Sifton said:

    The accuracy of the movie Argo is painful to the Canadian people who worked at the Canadian Embassy in Tehran. As President Carter said last week … 90% of the planning was done by the Canadian’s … Ambassador Ken Taylor and his staff risked their lives to help the Americans. Tony Mendez (Affleck’s character) was only in Tehran for one and a half days. The CIA almost blew it … for the forged visa’s they made had the wrong dates … they had them leaving before they entered Iran. Many many scenes in the movie never happened … but that is Hollywood … the sad thing is that many American’s will believe as being true. Also Afflects diss of Ken Taylor is embarrassing for those that know! … The question to ask is how can a inaccurate movie like this win an Oscar … The answer … an ignorant/uneducated Academy. Sorry for my lame vent … but I am a Canadian and very proud of Ken Taylor and his staffs brave efforts to help their Neighbours and would like to see a true story of the real event and not Ben Afflect’s American propaganda jingoistic action film/movie portraying itself to be based on real events and ex CIA Tony Mendaz’s exaggeration of events which are pure fiction to make monies and fame. The other sad thing, is that Afflect spent time with Ken Taylor and did not listen to Taylor’s concern with the script writers interpretation of events … another diss.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.