[Mb-civic] Kerry's Response to Allawi
michael at michaelbutler.com
Thu Sep 23 21:58:21 PDT 2004
Go to Original
Senator John Kerry
Response to U.S.-Appointed Iraq Prime Minister Allawi Remarks
t r u t h o u t | Statement
Thursday 23 September 2004
It's great to be here at Fire Station No. 1 with Fire Chief Ned Pettus,
standing right here behind me and the deputy chiefs and the other
representatives of the department, and Mark Sanders, the president of the
firefighters. And I'm honored to be here with all of them.
I'm also delighted to be here with Senator John Glenn, who knows
something about security, about patriotism, and about putting your life on
your line for your country. And he shares deeply the thoughts that I will
express about Iraq and about our policy.
When you're at war, it is important to tell the truth to the American
people. I fought in a war when we weren't told the truth and I know the
consequences, and so does America. The president's words to our troops and
to the American people and to the world have to be based on the truth
because that's the way you bring people to the cause. That's how you earn
support. That's how you earn trust. That's how you bring alliances that are
important to our troops.
I want victory, I want to win, and I have a better plan to win than
George Bush does. The president says that things are getting better in Iraq
and we must just stay the same course. Well, I disagree. They're not getting
better, and we need to change the course to protect our troops and to win.
Before the war, the president said that there were lots of terrorists
causing the trouble; that's why we had to go to war. Just yesterday he says
to the American people, now that we are at war, that there are only a
handful of terrorists. And yet only two days earlier Prime Minister Allawi
said that's not true; thousands of terrorists are crossing the borders and
entering into Iraq. It has become a magnet for terrorism, and that is what
Secretary of State Colin Powell said.
We have an administration at disarray, the secretary of Defense saying
one thing and being corrected, the president saying one thing and being
contradicted by the prime minister, the secretary of State saying one thing
and being contradicted by the president. America needs leadership that tells
George Bush just yesterday said he was just -- the CIA was just
guessing on Iraq. Just guessing, America? The CIA? They're not just
guessing; they're giving the president of the United States their best
judgment. It's called an analysis. And the president ought to read it, and
he ought to study it, and he ought to respond to it.
The president says just stay the course and everything will be fine. I
laid out a plan in New York to win. I laid out a plan which will help
America protect our troops.
We need to bring other allies to the table. The president skedaddled
out of New York so quickly, he barely had time to talk to any leaders. We
need a summit. We need to bring people to the table. We need to behave like
we are at war and respect the lives of our soldiers that are being lost
because we are at war. They deserve better leadership. They deserve a
mission with a plan that can succeed.
A president's true test of leadership is how he responds when things
are going wrong. You need to be prepared to tell the truth. And I think that
a president who fails to admit his mistakes is a president who proves that
he doesn't know how to make the course correct.
A commander in chief's first obligation in time of war is to tell the
truth, to be straight with our soldiers and our citizens. That's what we
I have a plan to make us successful, and I wish the president would
implement that plan now.
Happy to answer any questions.
QUESTION: Senator, Prime Minister Allawi told Congress today that
democracy was taking hold in Iraq and that the terrorists there were on the
defensive. Is he living in the same fantasyland as the president?
SEN. KERRY: I think the prime minister is, obviously, contradicting his
own statement of a few days ago where he said the terrorists are pouring
into the country. The prime minister and the president are here, obviously,
to put their best face on the policy. But the fact is that the CIA
estimates, the reporting, the ground operations, and the troops all tell a
Yesterday I read the report of a deputy director of the coalition
authority, the Provisional Coalition Authority. He's now returned to the
United States. And his report was really pretty devastating. He wrote that
we are losing the peace. He wrote that we are not getting the reconstruction
aid out, that only 5 percent of the money has been spent. He wrote of the
levels of unemployment and of the difficulties of people who are earning
money throwing grenades at American soldiers. He wrote of the decisions that
this administration have made that have made this situation more difficult
than it needs to be.
I hope democracy will take hold. I want democracy to take hold. But at
the moment, at the moment, I think most people would tell you that the
United States and the Iraqis have retreated from whole areas of Iraq. There
are "no go" zones in Iraq today. You can't hold an election in an "no go"
So it's time to talk the truth and the reality about the numbers of
troops on the ground. I want success. Let me emphasize this. From day one, I
have said we need to be successful. From day one, I have offered a road to
success. From day one, this president has chosen a different course of
action, and we Americans are paying a price in the lives of our young and in
the dollars being spent by Americans because this president has stubbornly
refused to embrace good advice, and has stubbornly continued to pursue his
own road. I think it's the wrong road, and I think we need to change.
QUESTION: Senator, how would you as president stop the kidnappings and
SEN. KERRY: You have to provide security, and the only way to provide
security adequately is to rapidly train the forces. This administration has
not done that. I mean, we've -- look, if you're serious about this, folks,
put some people on a 747.
You know, I remember how we got plenty of troops into Vietnam on
chartered airliners. Why don't we put some people on airplanes and fly them
to countries and train them there, if their troops are unwilling to go into
the country? There are plenty of ways to do more rapid training. You could
do more rapid training in nearby countries.
Secretary Rumsfeld misled the American people about the numbers of
troops that have been trained. Look, he told America there were 210,000
armed forces. The secretary of Defense didn't tell the truth to the American
people. Then he told Congress there were 95,000. He didn't tell the truth to
the Congress. There were 5,000 -- 5,000. That's a disgrace. It's a disgrace
that the secretary of Defense doesn't tell the truth to the American people,
and it's a disgrace that this president doesn't hold anybody in his
administration accountable for failure.
These are not small miscalculations. These are miscalculations which
are costing lives, costing America's reputation in the world. These are
miscalculations of judgment. And that's what we hire a president for, is to
exercise the right judgment. I think this president has exercised the wrong
judgment from day one, and that's why we need a change.
QUESTION: You criticized the president for retreating from --
QUESTION: Senator, one of your ads yesterday --
QUESTION: -- you criticized -- to the A.P. -- the president for
retreating, I believe was your word, from Fallujah. Given the situation on
the ground in Fallujah when there was an offensive there -- when there was a
rising civilian death toll, a rising criticism among Arab media for our
actions there -- what would you have done differently as a --
SEN. KERRY: Let me tell you: I've said many times, I wouldn't have just
done one thing differently in Iraq; I would have done almost everything
differently. And when you people judge me, and the American people judge me,
on this, I want you to judge me on the full record. I stood in Fulton,
Missouri, and I gave the president advice about what he needed to do. He
didn't take it. I stood at Georgetown University a year and a half ago, and
I gave the president advice about what he needed to do. He didn't take it. I
stood on the floor of the Senate, gave him advice about what he needed to
do. He didn't take it. I've laid out a whole series of things I would have
done that would have prevented Fallujah.
Let me tell you, if the 4th Infantry Division -- and the diplomacy had
been done with Turkey, he wouldn't have had a Fallujah. This president
rushed to war without a plan to win the peace. And ask the military leaders;
go ask the military leaders. General Shinseki told this country how many
troops we'd need. The president retired him early for telling the truth.
That's why you have Fallujah. That's why you have a mess in Iraq. And that's
not the kind of leadership this nation deserves.
QUESTION: Senator --
SEN. KERRY: Thank you all very much. I appreciate it.
Jump to TO Features for Friday September 24, 2004
© Copyright 2004 by TruthOut.org
More information about the Mb-civic